No Result
View All Result
Friday, August 8, 2025
Almirsad
  • Home
  • Periodic Commentary
    Why Did the Muslim Ummah Fall Behind?

    Why Did the Muslim Ummah Fall Behind?

    Attack on Jaffer Express: Why the Blame Was Placed on Afghanistan

    Attack on Jaffer Express: Why the Blame Was Placed on Afghanistan

    The Arrest of Three High-Profile ISIS Operatives in Pakistan: What Does It Signify?

    The Arrest of Three High-Profile ISIS Operatives in Pakistan: What Does It Signify?

    The Policy of Exaggerating ISIS-K as a Global Threat: Who is Behind It, Why, and for What Purpose?

    The Policy of Exaggerating ISIS-K as a Global Threat: Who is Behind It, Why, and for What Purpose?

    Afghanistan-Pakistan Relations: A Circle in the Military Behind the Strife

    Afghanistan-Pakistan Relations: A Circle in the Military Behind the Strife

    Pakistan Seeks to Entangle China in a Regional Proxy War for Its Own Gains

    Pakistan Seeks to Entangle China in a Regional Proxy War for Its Own Gains

  • News
    • All
    • Afghanistan
    • Region
    • World
    Syrian Forces Capture Nine ISIS Militants in Idlib Raid

    Syrian Forces Capture Nine ISIS Militants in Idlib Raid

    ISIS Strikes Oil Tanker in Deir ez-Zor Amid Ongoing Extortion Campaign

    ISIS Strikes Oil Tanker in Deir ez-Zor Amid Ongoing Extortion Campaign

    Yazidi Families Still Searching for Loved Ones, a Decade After ISIS Assault

    Yazidi Families Still Searching for Loved Ones, a Decade After ISIS Assault

    ISIS-K Turns to Kidnapping and Extortion After Military Defeat

    ISIS-K Turns to Kidnapping and Extortion After Military Defeat

    ISIS Suffers Casualties in Al-Qaeda Attack in Burkina Faso

    ISIS Suffers Casualties in Al-Qaeda Attack in Burkina Faso

    Senior ISIS Commander Eliminated, Another Surrenders to Malian Armed Forces

    Senior ISIS Commander Eliminated, Another Surrenders to Malian Armed Forces

    • Afghanistan
    • Region
    • World
  • Articles
    • All
    • Islamic Articles
    • Jihadi Articles
    • Modern-Day Khawarij
    • Political Article
    From the Pages of History: The Ottoman Caliphate | Part 23 |

    From the Pages of History: The Ottoman Caliphate | Part 23 |

    ISIS: An Assault on Islam

    ISIS: An Assault on Islam

    Examining the Economic Machinery Behind the Daeshi Khawarij | Part 9 |

    Examining the Economic Machinery Behind the Daeshi Khawarij | Part 9 |

    ISIS: A Historical and Intellectual Inquiry | Part 6 |

    ISIS: A Historical and Intellectual Inquiry | Part 6 |

    Pathways to Radicalization: Understanding ISIS’s Recruitment Strategies

    Pathways to Radicalization: Understanding ISIS’s Recruitment Strategies

    The Army of Darkness: Understanding ISIS | Part 3 |

    The Army of Darkness: Understanding ISIS | Part 3 |

    • Modern-Day Khawarij
    • Political Article
    • Jihadi Articles
    • Islamic Articles
  • Scholars
    • All
    • Sheikh Rahimullah Haqqani
    The Onslaught Against Scholars: The Ultimate Degradation of the Modern-Day Khawārij

    The Onslaught Against Scholars: The Ultimate Degradation of the Modern-Day Khawārij

    The Obligation of the Ulema

    The Obligation of the Ulema

    A Concise Overview of the Life and Struggle of Martyr Mawlawi Abdul Haq Haqqani (Nu’man)

    A Concise Overview of the Life and Struggle of Martyr Mawlawi Abdul Haq Haqqani (Nu’man)

    The Esteemed Benefactor and Academic Figure of the Ummah

    The Esteemed Benefactor and Academic Figure of the Ummah

    “That mountain whose peaks will no longer be illuminated by the rays of the sun!   

    “That mountain whose peaks will no longer be illuminated by the rays of the sun!  

    • Sheikh Rahimullah Haqqani
    • Sheikh Sardarwali
  • Personalities of the Ummah
    The Life and Struggle of the Martyr Hikmatullah Muzammil (May Allah Accept Him)

    The Life and Struggle of the Martyr Hikmatullah Muzammil (May Allah Accept Him)

    Martyr Ismail Haniyeh: A Symbol of Jihad and Resistance

    Martyr Ismail Haniyeh: A Symbol of Jihad and Resistance

    The Anniversary of Haniyeh’s Martyrdom: Renewing Our Covenant with the Martyrs

    The Anniversary of Haniyeh’s Martyrdom: Renewing Our Covenant with the Martyrs

    The Life and Legacy of Martyr Saeid Azad Khan “Atal” – May Allah Accept Him

    The Life and Legacy of Martyr Saeid Azad Khan “Atal” – May Allah Accept Him

    Martyr Sheikh al-Islam Rahimullah Haqqani: The Mujahid Scholar and Daesh’s Fiercest Opponent

    Martyr Sheikh al-Islam Rahimullah Haqqani: The Mujahid Scholar and Daesh’s Fiercest Opponent

    A Beacon Extinguished: The Martyrdom of Sheikh Rahimullah Haqqani and ISIS’s War on Knowledge

    A Beacon Extinguished: The Martyrdom of Sheikh Rahimullah Haqqani and ISIS’s War on Knowledge

  • Productions
  • Infographics
  • Library
  • Almirsad
    • دري
    • پښتو
    • عربي
    • اردو
    • বাঙালি
  • Home
  • Periodic Commentary
    Why Did the Muslim Ummah Fall Behind?

    Why Did the Muslim Ummah Fall Behind?

    Attack on Jaffer Express: Why the Blame Was Placed on Afghanistan

    Attack on Jaffer Express: Why the Blame Was Placed on Afghanistan

    The Arrest of Three High-Profile ISIS Operatives in Pakistan: What Does It Signify?

    The Arrest of Three High-Profile ISIS Operatives in Pakistan: What Does It Signify?

    The Policy of Exaggerating ISIS-K as a Global Threat: Who is Behind It, Why, and for What Purpose?

    The Policy of Exaggerating ISIS-K as a Global Threat: Who is Behind It, Why, and for What Purpose?

    Afghanistan-Pakistan Relations: A Circle in the Military Behind the Strife

    Afghanistan-Pakistan Relations: A Circle in the Military Behind the Strife

    Pakistan Seeks to Entangle China in a Regional Proxy War for Its Own Gains

    Pakistan Seeks to Entangle China in a Regional Proxy War for Its Own Gains

  • News
    • All
    • Afghanistan
    • Region
    • World
    Syrian Forces Capture Nine ISIS Militants in Idlib Raid

    Syrian Forces Capture Nine ISIS Militants in Idlib Raid

    ISIS Strikes Oil Tanker in Deir ez-Zor Amid Ongoing Extortion Campaign

    ISIS Strikes Oil Tanker in Deir ez-Zor Amid Ongoing Extortion Campaign

    Yazidi Families Still Searching for Loved Ones, a Decade After ISIS Assault

    Yazidi Families Still Searching for Loved Ones, a Decade After ISIS Assault

    ISIS-K Turns to Kidnapping and Extortion After Military Defeat

    ISIS-K Turns to Kidnapping and Extortion After Military Defeat

    ISIS Suffers Casualties in Al-Qaeda Attack in Burkina Faso

    ISIS Suffers Casualties in Al-Qaeda Attack in Burkina Faso

    Senior ISIS Commander Eliminated, Another Surrenders to Malian Armed Forces

    Senior ISIS Commander Eliminated, Another Surrenders to Malian Armed Forces

    • Afghanistan
    • Region
    • World
  • Articles
    • All
    • Islamic Articles
    • Jihadi Articles
    • Modern-Day Khawarij
    • Political Article
    From the Pages of History: The Ottoman Caliphate | Part 23 |

    From the Pages of History: The Ottoman Caliphate | Part 23 |

    ISIS: An Assault on Islam

    ISIS: An Assault on Islam

    Examining the Economic Machinery Behind the Daeshi Khawarij | Part 9 |

    Examining the Economic Machinery Behind the Daeshi Khawarij | Part 9 |

    ISIS: A Historical and Intellectual Inquiry | Part 6 |

    ISIS: A Historical and Intellectual Inquiry | Part 6 |

    Pathways to Radicalization: Understanding ISIS’s Recruitment Strategies

    Pathways to Radicalization: Understanding ISIS’s Recruitment Strategies

    The Army of Darkness: Understanding ISIS | Part 3 |

    The Army of Darkness: Understanding ISIS | Part 3 |

    • Modern-Day Khawarij
    • Political Article
    • Jihadi Articles
    • Islamic Articles
  • Scholars
    • All
    • Sheikh Rahimullah Haqqani
    The Onslaught Against Scholars: The Ultimate Degradation of the Modern-Day Khawārij

    The Onslaught Against Scholars: The Ultimate Degradation of the Modern-Day Khawārij

    The Obligation of the Ulema

    The Obligation of the Ulema

    A Concise Overview of the Life and Struggle of Martyr Mawlawi Abdul Haq Haqqani (Nu’man)

    A Concise Overview of the Life and Struggle of Martyr Mawlawi Abdul Haq Haqqani (Nu’man)

    The Esteemed Benefactor and Academic Figure of the Ummah

    The Esteemed Benefactor and Academic Figure of the Ummah

    “That mountain whose peaks will no longer be illuminated by the rays of the sun!   

    “That mountain whose peaks will no longer be illuminated by the rays of the sun!  

    • Sheikh Rahimullah Haqqani
    • Sheikh Sardarwali
  • Personalities of the Ummah
    The Life and Struggle of the Martyr Hikmatullah Muzammil (May Allah Accept Him)

    The Life and Struggle of the Martyr Hikmatullah Muzammil (May Allah Accept Him)

    Martyr Ismail Haniyeh: A Symbol of Jihad and Resistance

    Martyr Ismail Haniyeh: A Symbol of Jihad and Resistance

    The Anniversary of Haniyeh’s Martyrdom: Renewing Our Covenant with the Martyrs

    The Anniversary of Haniyeh’s Martyrdom: Renewing Our Covenant with the Martyrs

    The Life and Legacy of Martyr Saeid Azad Khan “Atal” – May Allah Accept Him

    The Life and Legacy of Martyr Saeid Azad Khan “Atal” – May Allah Accept Him

    Martyr Sheikh al-Islam Rahimullah Haqqani: The Mujahid Scholar and Daesh’s Fiercest Opponent

    Martyr Sheikh al-Islam Rahimullah Haqqani: The Mujahid Scholar and Daesh’s Fiercest Opponent

    A Beacon Extinguished: The Martyrdom of Sheikh Rahimullah Haqqani and ISIS’s War on Knowledge

    A Beacon Extinguished: The Martyrdom of Sheikh Rahimullah Haqqani and ISIS’s War on Knowledge

  • Productions
  • Infographics
  • Library
  • Almirsad
    • دري
    • پښتو
    • عربي
    • اردو
    • বাঙালি
No Result
View All Result
Almirsad
No Result
View All Result

Islamic Emirate vs. ISIS: Differences in Vision and Strategy

Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Written by: Asad Ghorzang

There exist significant foundational, Islamic, and political differences between the Islamic Emirate of Afghanistan (IEA) and ISIS (Daesh) concerning their vision and strategies.

RelatedPosts

Syrian Forces Capture Nine ISIS Militants in Idlib Raid

From the Pages of History: The Ottoman Caliphate | Part 23 |

ISIS: An Assault on Islam

The Islamic Emirate, a stable and credible movement since its establishment, differs profoundly from ISIS in various Islamic, cultural, foundational, and political aspects. Below, we examine some of the differences and positions of ISIS and the Islamic Emirate on key topics for better understanding.

1. The Islamic Emirate
– Geographic Focus:
The Islamic Emirate focuses entirely on the geographical boundaries of Afghanistan, emphasizing the implementation of Sharia within the country. It operates under an organized leadership structure led by the “Amir al-Mu’minin”, who is selected through a consultative council (shura). Decisions are made collectively through mutual consultation.

– Governance Goals:
The Islamic Emirate is committed to establishing a stable government, ensuring functional state institutions, and delivering services efficiently. It prioritizes the application of Sharia through moderation, respecting local cultural and traditional norms.

– Moderation in Takfir (Excommunication):
The Islamic Emirate is cautious about labeling individuals as apostates (murtadd). They only deem someone an apostate if the person explicitly commits an act of disbelief.

– Leaders and members of the Islamic Emirate follow the Hanafi school of thought within Ahl al-Sunnah wal-Jama’ah. They respect the opinions of Hanafi scholars and show full respect for other Sunni schools of thought. They also make a concerted effort to protect religious minorities, including Shia Muslims, ensuring their safety.

– Public Relations:
The Islamic Emirate enjoys significant support and cooperation from the general public. It actively addresses citizens’ complaints, resolves their issues promptly, and often consults with the populace on governance, administration, and development matters.

– Relations with the Islamic World:
The Islamic Emirate seeks to build ties with Muslim nations and considers itself a supporter of Islamic unity. It refrains from interfering in the internal affairs of other Islamic movements or states. Their stance is firmly rooted in the implementation of Sharia without extremes, interpreting Quranic verses and Prophetic traditions based on the guidance of Hanafi scholars.

2. ISIS (Daesh)
– Global Claims:
ISIS falsely claims to establish a global caliphate and uses this narrative to deceive people into advancing its political goals. It rejects all traditional structures and insists on imposing its rigid ideology.

– Methods of Control:
ISIS suppresses any opposition within its territories with extreme measures, destabilizing the entire Islamic world based on its flawed ideology, branding anyone who disagrees as an apostate.

– Tactics and Approach:
ISIS employs terror tactics, such as mass killings, bombings, and dissemination of gruesome videos, to instill fear and achieve its objectives. It operates under a dictatorial leadership where the leader holds absolute power, with minimal or no role for consultation.

– Governance and Strategy:
ISIS prioritizes spreading conflicts and fear over establishing governance structures, leading to its failure to build sustainable administrations. Its application of Sharia is marked by cruelty and is limited to its extremist interpretation, rejecting regional cultures or traditions not aligned with its views.

– Excess in Takfir:
ISIS is extremely rigid in declaring Muslims as apostates, often targeting those who support Islamic systems (such as the Taliban), deeming them misguided or outside the fold of Islam. They reject the jurisprudential methodologies of Hanafi, Shafi’i, or other Sunni schools, operating solely on their radical interpretations.

– Extreme Interpretations:

ISIS enforces an absolutist interpretation of Quranic verses and Prophetic traditions, dismissing alternative views and prioritizing its ideology above all else.

– Harsh Treatment of People:
ISIS imposes compliance through fear and brutality. Those who refuse to align with its ideology are labeled as disbelievers or traitors and are often executed.

– Exploitation of Resources:
ISIS is notorious for exploiting local resources and imposing heavy taxes on people. Those who fail to comply face severe punishments.

Conclusion:
The Islamic Emirate and ISIS represent fundamentally different ideologies and strategies. While the Islamic Emirate emphasizes stability, moderation, and adherence to traditional Islamic jurisprudence, ISIS promotes chaos, extremism, and unrelenting brutality.

ShareTweet
Previous Post

Factors Leading to the Decline of the Islamic Ummah | Part 1 |

Next Post

A Precise Analysis of the Relationship Between the Kharijites and America

RelatedArticles

The Islamic World’s Responsibility Towards ISIS Part Four
Modern-Day Khawarij

The Islamic World’s Responsibility Towards ISIS Part Four

June 15, 2024
The Khawārij: Masters of Takfīr, Perpetrators of Major Sins | Part 8 |
Articles

The Khawārij: Masters of Takfīr, Perpetrators of Major Sins | Part 8 |

June 4, 2025
The Failure of Extremist and Hardline Politics
Articles

The Failure of Extremist and Hardline Politics

December 1, 2024
“Us VS Them: The Eternal Struggle of Truth and Falsehood”
Articles

“Us VS Them: The Eternal Struggle of Truth and Falsehood”

September 9, 2024
The Last Two Decades of Occupation and Its Destructive Impact
Articles

The Last Two Decades of Occupation and Its Destructive Impact

March 19, 2025
The Failed Attempt of the Kharijites in al-Andalus During the Fall of the Umayyads
Articles

The Failed Attempt of the Kharijites in al-Andalus During the Fall of the Umayyads

November 25, 2024
Next Post
A Precise Analysis of the Relationship Between the Kharijites and America

A Precise Analysis of the Relationship Between the Kharijites and America

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    • Trending
    • Comments
    • Latest
    Is Muhammad Sharif Jafar, the ISIS Operative Arrested in Pakistan, Truly the Mastermind Behind the Kabul Airport Attack?

    Is Muhammad Sharif Jafar, the ISIS Operative Arrested in Pakistan, Truly the Mastermind Behind the Kabul Airport Attack?

    March 5, 2025
    A high-ranking ISIS delegation meets with ISIS-K leadership in Balochistan

    A high-ranking ISIS delegation meets with ISIS-K leadership in Balochistan

    February 25, 2025
    Acquired: List of Several Key Individuals Marked for Elimination by ISIS in Pakistan

    Acquired: List of Several Key Individuals Marked for Elimination by ISIS in Pakistan

    October 8, 2024
    Pakistan’s Story Reaches Its Conclusion

    Pakistan’s Story Reaches Its Conclusion

    March 28, 2024
    Al-Qaeda, Foreign Policy (FP) and Afghanistan

    Al-Qaeda, Foreign Policy (FP) and Afghanistan

    0
    “The Sincere Leader of the Sincere Nation”

    “The Sincere Leader of the Sincere Nation”

    0
    BNM Chairman: ISIS Has Active Camps in Balochistan

    BNM Chairman: ISIS Has Active Camps in Balochistan

    0
    Pakistan’s Story Reaches Its Conclusion

    Pakistan’s Story Reaches Its Conclusion

    0
    Syrian Forces Capture Nine ISIS Militants in Idlib Raid

    Syrian Forces Capture Nine ISIS Militants in Idlib Raid

    August 8, 2025
    From the Pages of History: The Ottoman Caliphate | Part 23 |

    From the Pages of History: The Ottoman Caliphate | Part 23 |

    August 7, 2025
    ISIS Strikes Oil Tanker in Deir ez-Zor Amid Ongoing Extortion Campaign

    ISIS Strikes Oil Tanker in Deir ez-Zor Amid Ongoing Extortion Campaign

    August 6, 2025
    ISIS: An Assault on Islam

    ISIS: An Assault on Islam

    August 5, 2025

    Latest News

    Syrian Forces Capture Nine ISIS Militants in Idlib Raid

    Syrian Forces Capture Nine ISIS Militants in Idlib Raid

    August 8, 2025
    From the Pages of History: The Ottoman Caliphate | Part 23 |

    From the Pages of History: The Ottoman Caliphate | Part 23 |

    August 7, 2025
    ISIS Strikes Oil Tanker in Deir ez-Zor Amid Ongoing Extortion Campaign

    ISIS Strikes Oil Tanker in Deir ez-Zor Amid Ongoing Extortion Campaign

    August 6, 2025
    ISIS: An Assault on Islam

    ISIS: An Assault on Islam

    August 5, 2025
    • Is Muhammad Sharif Jafar, the ISIS Operative Arrested in Pakistan, Truly the Mastermind Behind the Kabul Airport Attack?

      Is Muhammad Sharif Jafar, the ISIS Operative Arrested in Pakistan, Truly the Mastermind Behind the Kabul Airport Attack?

      0 shares
      Share 0 Tweet 0
    • A high-ranking ISIS delegation meets with ISIS-K leadership in Balochistan

      0 shares
      Share 0 Tweet 0
    • Acquired: List of Several Key Individuals Marked for Elimination by ISIS in Pakistan

      0 shares
      Share 0 Tweet 0
    • Pakistan’s Story Reaches Its Conclusion

      0 shares
      Share 0 Tweet 0
    • ISIS or the perpetrators of harm to the aspirations of the Muslim Ummah?

      0 shares
      Share 0 Tweet 0
    • Library
    Contact: info@almirsaad.com

    all rights are reserved for Muslims.

    Welcome Back!

    Login to your account below

    Forgotten Password?

    Retrieve your password

    Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

    Log In

    Add New Playlist

    No Result
    View All Result
    • Home
    • Periodic Commentary
    • News
      • Afghanistan
      • Region
      • World
    • Articles
      • Modern-Day Khawarij
      • Political Article
      • Jihadi Articles
      • Islamic Articles
    • Scholars
      • Sheikh Rahimullah Haqqani
      • Sheikh Sardarwali
    • Personalities of the Ummah
    • Productions
    • Infographics
    • Library
    • Almirsad
      • دري
      • پښتو
      • عربي
      • اردو
      • বাঙালি

    all rights are reserved for Muslims.

    Go to mobile version